AUSTRALIAN SPACEGUARD SURVEY

Links: Map of very recent Earthquakes in the Australian region and current tsunami warnings for the Pacific Ocean and Indian Ocean - all US sites!
Indian Ocean [Earthquake] Tsunami 26 Dec 2004
Is Sydney at risk?
Australia tsunami news
Asteroid Impact Tsunami
Tsunami Links
Books

This page is mainly concerned with prevention of future tsunami disasters.[TPSAVC Site map]

Australia

USGS: Map of very recent Earthquakes in the Australian region and current tsunami warnings for the Pacific Ocean - both US sites.  Historical Australian earthquakes.

Reduce your personal risk - May 2008

Be alert and prepared - not alarmed.  This is a low-probability, high-consequence event that calls for a little preparation in case a warning is issued.  These are similar to the things that people in tropical locations do to prepare for cyclone warnings.

Although the likelihood of a mega-tsunami is low there are some simple things you can do to significantly reduce the risk:
  1. Identify if you live, work or play in a vulnerable location - find out the approximate height above mean sea level. As a rough guide coastal and estuary land less than 10 metres above mean sea level is "at risk" and 5m or less should be considered "vulnerable". Google Maps has a sea level rise add-on that can give a very rough guide (detailed modelling is needed to assess vulnerability as there are many factors that influence tsunami inundation). The following links are to JPG screen snapshots from Google Maps - red shows 5m contour and yellow shows 10m contour - be prepared for a shock: - Narrabeen, Manly, Sydney , Brisbane, Gold Coast, Sunshine Coast, Nowra, Wollongong, Gosford, Newcastle and Forster
  2. Identify a safe location to go to in the event of a tsunami warning - a nearby hill or headland or at least the third storey of a reinforced concrete building
  3. Plan an evacuation route to reach that safe location (avoid the need for driving a car because the roads will likely gridlock)
  4. Subscribe to the email or RSS warning service of the US Pacific Tsunami Warning Center
  5. Consider subscribing to a mobile phone alert service like the Tsunami Institute in Germany or Tsunami SMS (expect about 5 warnings a month for the Pacific Ocean and maybe one per year relevant to your location) 
  6. If you receive a tsunami warning that is relevant to your location, or feel an earthquake, quickly get your evacuation plan into action. If a mega-tsunami does inundate the area do not return to low-lying land for at least 2 hours as other waves are likely to follow after the first wave and each wave can last for 20 to 30 minutes.
  7. Approach your local council and ask them to develop a tsunami warning action plan and infrastructure (such as a public address system) and to have inundation modelling carried out.
  8. Most importantly, relax and enjoy living near the ocean, knowing that you have made basic preparations for a worst case scenario

Update March 2008 

DRAFT presentation on the hazard to Sydney - including recent computer modelling of a mega-tsunami from the Tongan Trench that has similar features to the 2004 Indian Ocean Tsunami.  The Joint Australian Tsunami Warning Centre - Opinion: the "alert" side of things is progressing well. The "response" and "preparedness" aspects are not so good!

May 08: This report reaches a similar conclusion - Taking a punch: Building a more resilient Australia - report "We need greater clarity on the precise management and coordination arrangements in the case, for example, of a devastating tsunami impacting on southeast Australia...The Commonwealth agency seen to be responsible for this, Emergency Management Australia (EMA), has no mandate, legislation or Cabinet endorsement with which to take command. The delivery of EMA functions for the most part is the result of goodwill on behalf of other agencies. This is clearly not a satisfactory situation."  "A $70 million early warning system is being set up to record any earthquakes that could trigger giant waves to strike the NSW coast but it’s not clear how communities get informed, particularly if a night-time incident occurred..."

Update July 2006 (see also Australian news)

Emergency Management Australia is working on an "Australian Tsunami Warning System" - good news and hopefully we will soon see the implementation of civil warning systems for Sydney coastlines.

Key points (thanks Mark Sullivan, Director Capability Development EMA):

2008 additions


Notes up to June 2006 - important see update above

Australia receives alerts from a US tsunami warning system but there appear to be no Australian coastal towns with a civil response program - no alarm systems and no training on what to do if a tsunami is coming. In the unlikely (annual risk maybe 1 in 1000) event of a major tsunami-generating phenomena off the coast of Australia (see below) the tsunami warning centres would be faced with the same dilemma as the 2004 tsunami in the Indian Ocean - they would know that coastlines are about to be devatastated but could not do anything to prevent a tragedy. "Will there be the means to relay information to those who live on and near the beaches?". Currently Australians living in low-lying coastal areas are no better prepared than the poor isolated coastal villages of Indonesia.
This German organisatio has a worldwide SMS alert service for mobile phones and advice: What is the right behaviour in the event of a tsunami alarm?

Since 1999 this web page has pointed out the  need to learn more about the risk to Australia's coastline from major tsunami - some of these recommendations have since been partially implemented but no civil warning system is in place for the most vulnerable locations like Sydney, Newcastle and Wollongong:

Quantify the threat to Australian coastlines from tsunami

(Extract from "Australian Spaceguard Survey: the Australian component of an international effort to detect Earth-threatening asteroids and comets" - May 1999. Responses from Australian politicians.)

Australian news items (latest at top)

Monday's tsunami alert exposed numerous flaws in the preparedness for a major tsunami along the east coast of Australia. Since 1999 I have pointed out the lack of tsunami preparedness in Australia.

The report today in the Manly Daily is focussed on the dissemination of warning information but that is relatively straight forward. I subscribe to the Pacific Tsunami Warning Center's email alert service and received the first warning at 7.53am:
A TSUNAMI WARNING IS IN EFFECT FOR
 SOLOMON IS. / PAPUA NEW GUINEA
FOR ALL OTHER PACIFIC AREAS, THIS MESSAGE IS AN ADVISORY ONLY.

10 minutes later this was upgraded to include Australia:
A TSUNAMI WARNING IS IN EFFECT FOR
 SOLOMON IS. / PAPUA NEW GUINEA / VANUATU / NAURU / CHUUK /
 NEW CALEDONIA / POHNPEI / KOSRAE / AUSTRALIA / INDONESIA /
 TUVALU / KIRIBATI / MARSHALL IS.
...
ESTIMATED INITIAL TSUNAMI WAVE ARRIVAL TIMES. ACTUAL ARRIVAL TIMES
MAY DIFFER AND THE INITIAL WAVE MAY NOT BE THE LARGEST. THE TIME
BETWEEN SUCCESSIVE TSUNAMI WAVES CAN BE FIVE MINUTES TO ONE HOUR.

 LOCATION                            COORDINATES     ARRIVAL TIME
 --------------------------------    ------------    ------------
 SOLOMON IS.      MUNDA               8.4S 157.2E    2039Z 01 APR
                  FALAMAE             7.4S 155.6E    2103Z 01 APR
...
AUSTRALIA        CAIRNS             16.7S 145.8E    2349Z 01 APR
                  BRISBANE           27.2S 153.3E    0033Z 02 APR
                  SYDNEY             33.9S 151.4E    0114Z 02 APR
                  GLADSTONE          23.8S 151.4E    0139Z 02 APR
                  MACKAY             21.1S 149.3E    0144Z 02 APR
                  HOBART             43.3S 147.6E    0245Z 02 APR
(times are Universal/GMT so 0114Z equates to 11.14am in Sydney)

The big flaw exposed on Monday was the lack civil preparedness:
a) In Australia there are no computer models of shoaling tsunami to predict the size of a tsunami when it reaches the coast, based on its direction and deep water amplitude
b) There are no inundation models to predict which areas are at risk from tsunami of various sizes and no civil disaster plans to deal with such inundations.
c) There is no way to reliably and quickly warn the thousands of people in these areas (Sri Lanka now has air-raid style sirens along its coast).
d) People have not been taught what to do if they receive a tsunami warning (Pacific Islanders have been shown videos of tsunami to help them understand what to do. In Japan and Hawaii there are planned evacuation routes).

In short, some people who should have moved a safety did not and many people who were in no danger took unnecessary action and added to the disruption.

A typical misinformed comment of a person on the beach (with a young family!) was that they would wait until the sea receded before running to a high place. Firstly, the trough does not always arrive before the peak of the wave and secondly, as shown in the graphic videos from the Indian Ocean tsunami, people have no chance of out-running a tsunami. Tsunami move much faster than a normal ocean wave.

Although there were a few hours warning on Monday this is not always the case. For example, there are several examples of underwater landslide tsunami where a huge portion of the continental slope collapsed, often triggered by a minor earthquake. The continental slope off the coast of Sydney has not been surveyed for this risk and, in hindsight, the Newcastle Earthquake of 1989 should have been treated as a potential tsunami event.

Regards
Michael Paine


Caption: Underwater survey showing a landslide on the continental slope
between Sydney and Wollongong. It is about twice the size of Botany
Bay and the depth is greater than the height of Mt Kosciuszko.
This image has an exaggerated vertical scale.


Not so rare!

Tsunami in the 1990s  Killer tsunami in historical times
Click for larger image. May be reproduced with credit to this page or Michael Paine.

Indian Ocean Tsunami (see also other tsunami news)

Comment on the SE Asian tsunami disaster, 26 Dec 04.

This horrific tsunami was caused by an earthquake - not an asteroid - but the consequences are similar.  Like the asteroid threat, warnings from experts about the risk and consequences of major tsunami have been largely ignored, except in Japan and Western USA.

Japan and the USA have a very a effective tsunami warning system in the Pacific Ocean. It is based, partly, on pressure sensors on the ocean floor. Tsunami waves are so long that they change the pressure at the seafloor whereas wind waves get smoothed out.

It would be possible to set up a similar tsunami warning system in the Indian Ocean - for a few $million (ie the cost of a few cruise missiles)!  However some locations, such as Sumartra, were probably too close to the source of the tsunami for a warning system to be effective and in other areas communication limitations might hinder evacuation.

The threat in this area is well documented - STH Abstract (1999): Tsunamis along the coastlines of India + Tsunamis recorded along the coast of India. 2007 STH : A CATALOG OF TSUNAMIS IN THE INDIAN OCEAN

Jan 07: IndoTsunami web site -  developing a Regional Tsunami Warning and Mitigation System for the Indian Ocean

Jan 07: Excellent presentation by Steve Ward on the tsunami hazard (19Mb Quicktime movie)

Updates related to the Indian Ocean Tsunami (latest at top)